The Mayor of Hell’s Kitchen Goes to Crime School

hells_kitchen_largea19393

     I was watching “Hell’s Kitchen” the other night, a 1939 Warner Brothers programmer with The Dead End Kids. They were still riding the crest of a wave of success that began with William Wyler’s “Dead End” and continued with films like “Angels with Dirty Faces,” and the lesser successful “Angels Wash Their Faces.” This is, of course, before they began deteriorating into overaged caricatures of their former selves as they continuously changed names, from The Dead End Kids to The East Side Kids to The Little Tough Guys and finally the Bowery Boys. Moving from major studios like Warners Brothers and Universal to the depths of poverty row with Monogram. What struck me about the Hell’s Kitchen was this feeling of déjà vu, I had seen the film once before but that was not why I had the feeling. Somehow, I thought Humphrey Bogart was in this film or maybe it was James Cagney. In addition, to The Dead End Kids, “Hell’s Kitchen” starred Ronald Reagan (who also appeared with the boys in “Angels Wash Their Faces”) billed way down on the list of characters after all the DEK’s!

mayorof-lbby-card

    About halfway into the film, it struck me that “Hell’s Kitchen” was similar to the Humphrey Bogart film “Crime School” made just the year before. While there are differences between the films, the similarities are striking beginning with the fact both films are directed by Lewis Seiler, and Crane Wilber is given credit for both the story and co-screenwriting on each film. Then it came to me there is another similar film, 1933’s “The Mayor of Hell” where young James Cagney plays a reformed gangster who takes over a juvenile reformatory attempting to fix a corrupt system, which was what Ronald Reagan’s almost reformed gangster father-in-law Stanley Fields does in “Hell’s Kitchen.”

 All three films contain corrupt sadistic superintendents. Both “Crime School” and “Hell’s Kitchen” have scenes where the juvenile inmates establish a self-governing system though, in “Hell’s Kitchen” it is sanctioned by the officials in charge whereas in “Hell’s Kitchen”, it quickly turns to a lynch mob mentality. In “Crime School”, Bogart, a deputy commissioner, takes over the corrupt reformatory, as does lawyer Reagan in “Hell’s Kitchen.”  In “The Mayor of Hell”, a young James Cagney plays as a reformed gangster who takes over a juvenile reformatory attempting to fix a corrupt system.

crime-school11476

    Of course, all the films have caring, beautiful leading women. In the “Mayor of Hell”, it is the lovely Madge Evans, while it is Margaret Lindsay who attempts to take care of the boys in “Hell’s Kitchen.” “Crime School’s” leading lady Gale Page is a bit different as she is the older sister of juvenile problem child Billy Halop.  One difference between the films is that “The Mayor of Hell” is pre-code while the other two films, made late in the decade, were more restricted in what they could show.                                                                                                      

    Today, remakes, sequels are almost an expected part of movie going. Can anyone imagine a summer season without a remake or a sequel?  We know creativity and the financial guts to take chances is a rare commodity in Hollywood. With these three films, we are given a snapshot that taking chances and looking how to save a buck in Hollywood is not new.  Warner Brothers recycled the same story, and in the case of two of the three films, the same actors (The Dead End Kids), the same director and the same writer, all within six years. That’s economy.

     None of the films could be called great but all are entertaining, however, “The Mayor of Hell” shines with good  performances by Cagney and Frankie Darro and “Crime School”, is well worth your time if for no other reason than it has Bogart. “Hell’s Kitchen” biggest problem is really a lack of a strong leading man. Ronald Reagan comes across as just bland. Of the three films, “The Mayor of Hell” is the only one available on DVD.  Your best bet to catch the other two films is when they occasionally appear on TCM or download on-line.

Advertisements

5 comments on “The Mayor of Hell’s Kitchen Goes to Crime School

  1. Judy says:

    Hi John, love your headline!! I was very interested to read this posting, as I’ve been trying to get hold of ‘Crime School’ to see how it compares with ‘The Mayor of Hell’ – and how different Bogart is in the lead from Cagney. I would be interested to see ‘Hell’s Kitchen’ too.

    My DVD of ‘The Mayor of Hell’ includes trailers for the other two films and I think the commentary mentions that they are remakes/reworkings of the same story, but doesn’t go into any detail about the changes.

    Like

  2. John Greco says:

    Thanks Judy, I wasn’t going to write about watching ‘Hell’s Kitchen” till I started noticing the similarities between it and the two other films. I was just surprised that Warner Brothers recycled scripts in such a short period of time. “Crime School” and “Hell’s Kitchen”were within a year!

    Like

  3. Larry Pelliccioni says:

    Where does one find a dvd copy of Hell’s Kitchen. I am curious to know if there is a scene in the movie in which Leo Gorcey was playing hockey. If you will email me I can share with you the exciting reason why.
    Thank you.
    Larry Pelliccioni

    Like

  4. […] John Greco goes over The Mayor of Hell‘s two remakes, which were 1938′s Crime School and 1939′s Hell’s Kitchen. Crime School has Humphrey Bogart in the Cagney role, and Hell’s Kitchen has Ronald Reagan in the expanded role of a lawyer. Both of those two versions (released a year apart!) starred Warner’s stable of ‘Dead End Kids’, who originated in Angels With Dirty Faces… which starred James Cagney and Humphrey Bogart. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s